How Much Does a New Furnace Cost? Replacement Vs. Repair

Published on January 8, 2025 by: alhhvac

Consider Furnace Replacement and Repair Costs Before Choosing Either Option

It’s important to have a furnace you can count on, especially during the cold winter months. When temperatures drop, you need a furnace that keeps your home warm and comfortable. However, if your system is having problems, you might find yourself asking, “how much does a new furnace cost?” or “how much does it cost to replace a furnace?”

This guide provides a comprehensive look at furnace replacement cost and the overall furnace cost of a new unit. Our experts will also explore how new furnace cost differs between gas and electric furnaces, when to repair vs. replace a furnace, and average furnace replacement costs in Atlanta, GA — alongside providing a few answers to frequently asked questions (FAQs) about furnace repair and replacement.

Cost Differences Between Gas and Electric Furnaces

The cost of a new furnace depends on the type of furnace you choose. The two most common types are gas furnaces and electric furnaces. For both gas and electric furnaces, the overall furnace cost depends on installation and operating expenses. Gas furnaces generally have:

• Higher upfront installation costs.
• Lower operating costs in areas with affordable natural gas.
• More cost savings over time if natural gas is available.

Meanwhile, electric furnaces generally have:

• Lower upfront installation costs.
• Potentially higher electricity bills over time.
• More cost savings over time if your home doesn’t have a gas hookup.

In summary, the ultimate balance in cost savings between gas furnaces and electric furnaces is directly linked to whether or not your home has access to natural gas.

When to Repair vs. Replace a Furnace

Deciding between furnace repair and replacement depends on its age, repair history, and current efficiency. These factors impact both furnace replacement costs and new furnace costs, so it’s crucial to evaluate your system before making any decisions.

When to Repair a Furnace

You should consider repairing your furnace when:

• Your furnace is less than 10 years old.
• Your furnace’s issue is minor, such as a:
  • Faulty thermostat.
  • Clogged filter.
  • Dairy burner.
• Repair cost is less than 50% of replacement cost.

In all these cases, repairing a furnace is typically more effective than replacing it.

When to Replace a Furnace

You should consider replacing your furnace if:

• Your furnace is 15 years or older.
  • If between 10 and 15 years old, hire a professional maintenance person to give a recommendation between repair and replacement.
• Your furnace already requires frequent repairs and increasing energy bills.
• Your furnace faces major issues like:
  • Cracked heat exchangers.
  • Uneven heating.
  • Ignition Issues.
• The upfront cost of a new system is lower than your ongoing repair and energy expenses.

Average Furnace Costs in the Atlanta Service Area

The cost of a new furnace in Atlanta varies based on several factors, including the furnace type, efficiency rating, and installation complexity. On average, furnace replacement costs in Atlanta, GA range from $2,400 to $5,400, depending on the unit and labor expenses. The average cost of furnace installation in Augusta, GA is similar, yet there may be slight variations due to local factors such as contractor availability and seasonal demand.

Furnace Replacement Costs for Different Types of Furnaces

Typical replacement costs for different types of furnaces are as follows:

• Gas Furnace Replacement: $2,400 – $5,400
• Electric Furnace Replacement: $2,000 – $3,600

Generally, electric furnaces are less expensive to replace than gas furnaces.

Furnace Repair Costs in Atlanta, Georgia

For those considering furnace repair instead of replacement, furnace repair costs in Georgia vary based on the extent of the repair. Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Minor repairs: $140 – $400
• Major repairs: $1,500 – $2,000

On average, repair costs tend to run anywhere from $140-$2,000 — quite a range for homeowners. If you’re considering repairing or replacing your furnace, you should talk to a professional repairman to get an estimate on which route will save you the most money.

Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Furnace in Atlanta With ALH

Deciding whether to repair or replace your furnace is a significant investment, and understanding furnace replacement costs, new furnace costs, and furnace repair costs can help you make an informed choice. If your furnace is aging or inefficient, upgrading to a high-efficiency model could lead to lower energy bills, better heating performance, and fewer future repairs.

For homeowners looking to maximize savings, ALH’s limited-time offer makes upgrading easier than ever. Our special offers page always has the latest deals we’re providing on furnaces — making it consistently affordable to invest in a high-efficiency, long-lasting system while keeping costs low.

Don’t miss out on this exclusive deal—contact ALH today for a free quote!